More than 50 athletes took the stage at the James and Rosemary Phalen Leadership Academy on Nov. 14 for the NPC Natural Indianapolis Championships, a drug-free bodybuilding competition featuring competitors—mostly from Indiana—in group and individual posing routines.
The all-day event included divisions for Bodybuilding, Classic Physique, Physique, Figure, Bikini, Wellness, Fitness and Fit Model. Athletes met from 8:30 to 9:30 a.m., followed by prejudging from 10 a.m. to noon and finals from 1 to 2:30 p.m.
Organizer Jesse Dale acknowledged the physical toll of competition as athletes prepared to pose.
“How are we feeling today, good? No, you’re not,” Dale said. “You’ve done your job dieting.”
Among the competitors was Amanda Caito of Fishers, who won first place in Novice and second place in Open Class A in Women’s Figure. Caito has 10 years of bodybuilding experience, but the competition marked her second show since switching from Bikini to Figure.
“They run a really nice show,” Caito said. “It’s a natural show. That’s nice, as a natural competitor, that you can get in on an even playing field.”
Caito is balancing bodybuilding with doctoral studies, parenting and a full-time job. She jokes that she wants to become a “doctor pro-athlete,” and her ultimate goal is to earn an IFBB Pro card. She said the sport has helped her develop the discipline to pursue demanding goals while also giving her a sense of community, joy and accomplishment.
“It has given me such a level of discipline and dedication … and probably a high level of hubris,” she said. “It allows me to do things like pursue a doctorate.”
Caito’s husband, Juan Marcucci, has been her biggest supporter and first encouraged her to try bodybuilding when they began dating. Sharing the sport, he said, has helped them understand and support each other through the demands of training and competition.
“Because we were doing it as a married couple, it really brought us together,” Marcucci said. “We know what the other one is going through, and we can support each other.”
That preparation can be grueling. After building muscle, competitors typically enter a 12- to 20-week “prep” period focused on losing fat while maintaining muscle. The final seven days, known as “peak week,” involve fine-tuning their physiques for the show. Marcucci said extreme dieting and training can leave athletes dealing with brain fog and a feeling similar to jet lag.
Competitors also have to carefully transition back to regular eating after a show, Caito said, rather than abruptly changing their diets. IFBB Pro judge and event head judge Jimmy Hornback noted that preparing for competition often means giving up time and routines.
“Everybody has made sacrifices,” Hornback said. “You’ve done 5 a.m. cardio. You’ve missed meals with the family and things with the kids you wanted to do.”
Competitor Colin Schafer said persistence is essential during preparation.
“You just gotta be willing to put your mind to it and keep going,” Schafer said. “Like, yeah, it sucks not eating what you want to eat, but if you have that goal in mind, you can do it. Just will yourself through it.”
Caito’s coach tailored her plan to account for her health challenges. She said her approach includes calculating macronutrients and choosing a more sustainable diet that accommodates cravings. Digestive issues already shape what she eats, and past restrictive dieting left her with lasting aversions to foods including egg whites and white fish.
After months of preparation, show day can feel like a celebration, Marcucci said. Dale encouraged family and friends in the auditorium to cheer for the competitors.
“This is the fun part,” Dale said. “We want to hear you loud. We want to hear you proud.”
Caito said the event had “immaculate vibes” and that meeting other competitors backstage helped distract her from her nerves. She planned to compete again the following week, meaning she would return to another peak week without the usual post-show break.
“I don’t even get a post-show meal,” she said. “I just get to jump right back into another peak week. But I think we’re gonna go get some food that I’ve been craving.”
After that competition, Caito planned to take the rest of the year to recover. She had previously competed in one bodybuilding show a year, but had completed three that year.
“I’m kind of ready to be done (this year),” she said. “I’m kind of ready to be a person again.”
Caito encouraged people curious about bodybuilding to consider trying it, or attend a show to see what competitors have put into their preparation.
“It’s a little insane, a little wild, but so much fun for the right person,” she said. “I welcome anyone to watch a show. You are watching years of passion and dedication and months of preparation.”
Dale said competitors’ stories can also encourage spectators pursuing their own fitness goals. One athlete at the Nov. 14 show, he said, had given birth seven months earlier—a reminder, he added, that people can make progress even while managing busy or challenging circumstances.
Results from the NPC Natural Indianapolis Championships and information about upcoming shows are available at NPCnews.com and resultz1.com.

